Finney Injury Law: Trial Lawyers Who Won't Back Down
Trial Lawyers Who Won't Back Down

Personal Attention.
Powerful Results.

St. Louis trial attorneys who are trial-tested and proven. That's what changes what insurance companies offer.

Request Your Free Consultation
Chris Finney, Founder and Trial Attorney
Chris Finney
Founder · Trial Attorney
The insurance industry has a phrase for firms who don't try cases. They call them settlement mills. Our firm is not one of them.
2025
Thomas G. Strong Award
Honors the Missouri attorney who best exemplifies professionalism, ethics, character, and demonstrated courtroom success.
Missouri Association of Trial Attorneys
Hensler
Daniel J. Hensler Award
in Trial Advocacy
Awarded for excellence in courtroom advocacy. Chris is also a regular presenter at continuing education events for trial lawyers nationwide.
St. Louis University School of Law
From the Founder

Why we're trial lawyers.

Before founding this firm, I had a variety of jobs in the legal world. At some point, I had to make a decision about what I wanted to be. After looking around and seeing what I had tried, being a trial lawyer was where I wanted to spend my time and efforts.

I did not want to be part of the firms that churn and burn and handle hundreds of cases per attorney. I did not want to defend insurance companies and act like I was defending an individual. I was simply saving insurance companies money at the expense of an injured person. That was an empty feeling.

As I grew in my career, I started to see that the most respected lawyers were those who tried cases, those who consistently took the cases to verdict and worked them up the right way. I saw that defense lawyers and insurance companies respected them. When I was an insurance defense lawyer, I saw how the insurance carriers and their lawyers feared real trial lawyers. It translated into real differences for their clients.

When I started Finney Injury Law, I aspired to build it around that experience. The leverage you have is a direct function of your willingness and ability to go to trial. Everything else is downstream of that. We strive to be trial lawyers.

What our firm actually does.

There is no shortage of personal injury lawyers. You can find tons of them with a quick Google search, a billboard, or a TV spot, and all of them tout their results. Some of those results are genuine, and some are not. Maybe somebody touts a result where they were a referring party or the fifth lawyer on. When I look around, I can see that everyone has a results page. You can check out ours too, if that's what you're looking for. We have eight-figure results, like many people do. If that's what you're looking for, you can check that box with ours.

Our firm is designed to be different. We do not take hundreds and hundreds of cases per attorney. We do not take cases based on quantity. We are not case brokers. We look for cases where we can provide effective and real value to you. We want to work for people we enjoy and can help.

I see many lawyers who tout their experience on the insurance defense side, saying they know what the defense or insurance company playbook is because they "wrote it." I worked on the defense side. There isn't any playbook other than to save money. That's the goal, and it is at the injured person's expense.

Our firm isn't built on knowing someone's playbook. It's built on our own. It's built on our interactions with our clients and their experiences. It's built on our experiences in actually trying cases. It's built on taking the time to investigate who our clients are and the facts of their cases, and to help them make the right decision for their case.

We do not prepare every case for trial. No one does that. Anyone who says that isn't being honest, but that doesn't mean we aren't ready to go to trial, or that we don't have the experience to. It doesn't mean we don't thoroughly work up cases. We do.

When I hear people say they prepare every case for trial, it's clear to me that they really don't go to trial, or that it's just marketing copy.

We have gone to trial, and will again, whenever the situation calls for it, but that decision is made with our clients' input and their needs and goals in mind. Each case needs to be handled uniquely. There is no one-size-fits-all. Being a trial lawyer is not running a factory or a settlement mill. It's being a human being who helps human beings.

If you're looking for a firm that will listen to you, advise you, counsel you, and guide you, you've found the right place. We are trial lawyers.

Read Chris's Full Story
Managing Attorney and Trial Lawyer

Alex Ledbetter.

Trial Lawyer · Courtroom-Tested Trial Attorney · Veteran Trial Attorney

Every case at Finney Injury Law gets an attorney's full attention. That isn't a marketing claim. With a hand-selected docket, there is no one else for cases to be handed off to.

Alex joined Chris in building the firm because they share a conviction most plaintiff lawyers won't say out loud: insurance companies pay more when they're forced to. The work that forces them to is preparation, and that's what we do.

30
Under 30
"30 Under 30"
Missouri Lawyers WeeklyRecognized for an exceptional record of trial victories at an early stage of his career, placing him among the top young trial attorneys in the state.
An Honor of the Missouri Bar
Read Alex's full story →
Alex Ledbetter, Managing Attorney
Alex Ledbetter
Managing Attorney
Trial Lawyer · Specialties: Medical Malpractice, Personal Injury

Approximately Eighteen Jury Trials.
State and Federal Court.

Jaclyn A. Kinkade, Trial Attorney at Finney Injury Law
Trial Attorney

Jaclyn A. Kinkade.

Fifteen years as a careerlong courtroom advocate. Jaclyn has personally tried approximately eighteen jury trials across civil and criminal matters, the kind of courtroom volume that's rare in plaintiff's work, and the reason she fits the firm.

Civil Defense Partner
Eight years at Cassiday Schade LLP, where she became a partner. Civil defense practice focused on medical malpractice and wrongful death, the same kind of cases she now tries from the plaintiff's side.
Former Prosecutor
Circuit Attorney's Office for the City of St. Louis. Promoted to senior domestic violence attorney in the Special Victim's Unit.
Appellate Experience
Three years in the Missouri Attorney General's Office, argued before the Missouri Court of Appeals.
Notable Result
One of her final jury trials as a prosecutor resulted in a guilty verdict for murder in the first degree.
Read Jaclyn's full story →
"Insurance companies know which firms settle quickly and which ones are prepared to go to trial."
A Truth the Industry Knows
The Math Behind the Difference

Two Approaches.
Two Very Different Outcomes.

Insurance companies know which law firms settle quickly and which ones are prepared to go to trial. That knowledge changes what they offer.

The Volume Model

Settle First.
Settle Fast.

Designed for the firm. Profitable for the firm. Often costly for the client.

  • i.
    Hundreds of cases at once.Volume drives revenue. Each individual case gets a fraction of the firm's attention.
  • ii.
    The first offer is the goal.Quick settlements close files. Closed files generate fees. The case moves on.
  • iii.
    Insurers know the pattern.Carriers track which firms try cases, and which don't. They price offers accordingly.
  • iv.
    Trial is the threat, not the plan.Cases that won't settle get referred out, dropped, or pushed to settle anyway.
A Selection of Recent Outcomes

Some firms talk about
going to trial.
We deliver results there.

The pattern repeats. Insurance companies undervalue serious cases. Trial preparation closes the gap. Below is a selection of recent verdicts and settlements from the Finney trial team, obtained by taking cases other firms might have settled.

Wrongful Death · Trucking
$0 $20M

Insurer's Initial Offer Was Zero. Jury Disagreed.

Tractor-trailer collision resulting in the death of a family's loved one. Defense initially refused to acknowledge liability. Eight-figure verdict followed full trial.

Jury Verdict · Missouri
Premises Liability · Aldi
$125K $2.5M

A Previous Lawyer Passed on This Case.

Property-condition injury at a national grocer. A prior firm declined the matter. After eighteen months of trial preparation, settlement reached two-and-a-half weeks before trial began.

Negotiated Settlement · Pre-Trial
Trucking Negligence
$1.25M

Construction Zone Rear-End Collision.

Commercial truck driver was over federal hours-of-service limits, had omitted log entries, and was using his phone at the moment of impact. Liability proven through carrier records.

Settlement · Missouri
Catastrophic Injury · Trial Verdict
$750K

Tried to Verdict. No Settlement Offer.

Case successfully tried by Chris Finney and Alex Ledbetter. Subsequently presented as a teaching case at Trial Lawyers University on courtroom strategy and trial advocacy.

Jury Verdict · 2022
Multimillion-Dollar Recoveries
Multiple

Beyond the Headline Verdicts.

Numerous additional multimillion-dollar recoveries across catastrophic injury, daycare negligence, traumatic brain injury, premises liability, and wrongful death matters.

Verified results upon request

Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Each case is unique and must be evaluated on its individual facts. Specific case results have been verified internally; certain identifying details have been adjusted to protect client privacy.

In Their Own Words

What Clients Actually Say
About Working With Us.

Reviews and testimonials submitted by real clients. The themes repeat: direct attorney access, responsiveness, and care that continued long after settlement.

"
Thorough and professional.
After my accident, I had so many questions and had no idea what to do next or who to turn to. I was referred to Finney Injury Law and all of my worries went away. They were so helpful in explaining the process, what to expect, and what I was entitled to. Highly recommended.
Verified Client Personal Injury Matter
"
Far exceeded my expectations.
Chris Finney's professionalism and guidance as my lawyer far exceeded my expectations. From the beginning, I knew that he not only valued me as a person, but he saw the value in pursuing my claim. He is smart, dedicated and will not fail to do his very best for his client.
Verified Client Personal Injury Matter
"
It was the personal attention.
What stood out about the Finney Injury Law experience was the personal attention. Direct contact with the attorney handling the case. Real conversations. Returned calls. A team that treated me like more than a file.
Larry Former Client
"
A man of integrity.
I have had the privilege of working with Chris Finney for several years. His strong work ethic and perseverance are the keys to his success. He is a man of integrity and acts in the best interests of his clients.
Professional Colleague Long-Term Working Relationship
"Some firms talk about going to trial.
We deliver results there."
Finney Injury Law
The Difference, Quantified

Why Trial Experience
Changes Your Outcome.

A recent client outcome
The verdict over the original
insurance offer.
In one recent case, when an insurance company offered our client a low seven-figure settlement, we supported his decision to go to trial and secured a verdict that was four times the original offer.
That's the difference working with a true trial firm can make.
i.

We're Trial-Tested and Proven.

We're trial-tested and proven, because that's how we consistently obtain better results for our clients.

ii.

A Track Record of Multimillion-Dollar Verdicts.

Led by Chris Finney and Alex Ledbetter, our team has secured numerous multimillion-dollar verdicts by taking cases other firms might settle.

iii.

Recognized Leaders in Personal Injury Litigation.

Chris is the 2025 recipient of the Thomas G. Strong Award. Alex was recently named to Missouri Lawyers Weekly's "30 Under 30" for his impressive track record of trial victories.

For Referring & Co-Counsel Attorneys

Why Other Firms Bring Us In as Co-Counsel.

When insurance companies see Finney Injury Law on a case, they know it may go to trial. That's not a threat. That's a track record.

Most personal injury firms in St. Louis are built around one thing: settling cases as fast as possible. That model works for the firm. It doesn't always work for the client.

At Finney Injury Law, each case gets a trial-tested and proven team. Your client gets the fighter they deserve. Your relationship with them stays protected. That's the Finney difference.

Insurance companies adjust their offers when they know the attorney across the table will actually walk into a courtroom. Most firms in this market never give them a reason to take it seriously. Finney Injury Law does.

The Choice You're Actually Making

The Big Firm You Saw on TV
vs. Finney Injury Law.

You won't feel like a number. You're represented by trial attorneys who won't back down from less than what you deserve.

High-Volume Firm
The Big Firm
You Saw on TV
Boutique Trial Firm
Finney
Injury Law
Caseload
Hundreds, sometimes thousands, of cases at any given time.
A focused caseload. Every client receives dedicated attention from our experienced trial team.
Who Handles Your Case
Often a paralegal or junior associate. The attorney on TV may never read your file.
Direct access to attorneys who have secured numerous multimillion-dollar verdicts.
Trial Strategy
Designed to settle. Trial is rare and reluctant.
Trial-tested and proven, because that's how we consistently obtain better results.
How You're Treated
A case number in a high-volume pipeline.
Treated like a person, not a case number. Personalized attention and honest communication.
When Insurers Won't Pay Fair Value
Pressure mounts to take what's offered and close the file.
We take cases other firms might settle, including a recent verdict 4× the original insurance offer.
Recognition
National brand recognition from advertising spend.
Recognition from peers: Thomas G. Strong Award, Daniel J. Hensler Award, Missouri Lawyers Weekly "30 Under 30."
A Few Things We Don't Do

What You Won't Find Here.

Most personal injury firms optimize for what works on other personal injury firms' websites. We don't. Here's what we've deliberately left out, and why.

i.

No TV commercials.

The firms you see on every local channel spent millions of dollars buying that airtime. That money comes out of client settlements. The high volume that advertising drives is exactly why those firms can't give any individual case serious attention. We invest in trial preparation instead of billboards.

ii.

No case decided without a lawyer.

Whoever you talk to first, your case is never accepted or turned away by someone without a law degree. An attorney personally reviews every case before we make a decision, and the attorney who reviews it is the attorney who works on it.

iii.

No promises about what your case is worth.

Any lawyer who tells you your case is worth a specific number before reviewing the facts is either lying or incompetent. Case value depends on injuries, liability, insurance limits, jurisdiction, and a dozen other factors we can't know from a first phone call. We'll give you an honest range once we've actually looked at the case.

iv.

No pressure to sign today.

The urgency tactics other firms use exist because fast signings are profitable. They are not in your interest. Talk to us. Talk to two other firms. Take a week. If we're the right fit, we'll still be here. And if we're not the right fit, we'll tell you that too.

v.

No cases we can't give real attention to.

Every case we accept gets a trial-tested and proven team. That means we can't accept every case that walks through the door. When we tell a caller "we're not the right firm for this," it's because we know we wouldn't be able to give the case the work it deserves. We'd rather send you to someone who will.

Honest Answers

The Questions People
Actually Ask.

There's no formula. Case value depends on the severity of your injuries, the long-term medical and life impact, lost earning capacity, the strength of liability evidence, applicable insurance limits, and the specific jurisdiction.

What we can tell you is this: the difference between what an insurance adjuster will offer and what a case is genuinely worth is often substantial. That's the entire reason firms like ours exist.

Most of our cases settle without a trial. But the firms that consistently get the best settlements are the ones genuinely prepared to go to court. Insurance companies know who tries cases and who doesn't, and they price their offers accordingly.

If your case settles, great. If it needs a jury, we're ready. Either way, you'll know what's happening and why at every step.

Most personal injury law firms won't say this out loud, but: sometimes settling is the right move. If the offer reflects the true value of the case, if liability is genuinely contested, if going to trial creates risk that outweighs the upside, settlement may be the smart decision.

Our job is to give you an honest assessment of both options, not to push you toward whichever one is more profitable for us.

It depends on the case. Simple cases with clear liability can resolve in months. Complex cases involving serious injuries, disputed liability, or commercial defendants typically take a year or more, sometimes two or three if the case proceeds to trial.

Faster isn't always better. Settling quickly often means accepting less. We'll be straightforward with you about realistic timelines from the first conversation.

It means you pay nothing upfront. We work on contingency. Our fee comes from a percentage of the recovery if your case is successful. If we don't recover anything for you, you owe us no attorney's fees.

The percentage is disclosed in writing before you sign anything, and we'll walk through exactly how it works during your case review.

Yes. We represent injury victims across Missouri and Illinois. Deadlines to file a claim vary by state and by the type of case, so if your incident occurred in Illinois, it's worth reaching out sooner rather than later to make sure you don't lose the ability to pursue your claim.

Start the Conversation

Tell Us What Happened.

A few fields. Our intake team listens first, then a founding attorney personally reviews your case with an honest assessment.

If we're not the right fit, we'll tell you, and we'll point you toward someone who is.

Confidential consultation. Your information stays between us.
Response within one business day. Often the same day.
If we're not the right fit, we'll tell you. And we'll point you toward someone who is.

Request a Case Review.

Takes less than 60 seconds.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not share confidential information.

A Final Word

You're Not a Case Number.

We're selective about the cases we take, and that's by design. It means your attorney knows your name, your story, and the details of your situation.

Real conversations. Returned calls. A strategy built around you, not a template. When we take your case, you get our full attention.

That's the only way we know how to practice law.

Investing in the Future

The Finney Injury Law Scholarship.

Two annual $10,000 awards to help deserving students overcome financial barriers to higher education. Tuition, books, housing, and LSAT preparation costs.

A small thing. But the kind of thing a firm only does when it isn't trying to sell you something.

Learn More About the Scholarship →
Request Case Review
Call Free Case Review